• Home
  • Plushies
    • Alien Plushie
    • Baby Baphomet Plushie
    • Bat Plushie
    • Bunny Plushie
    • Build a Bear Baphomet
    • Cat Plushies
    • Chibi Bat Plushies
    • Cow Plushies
    • Cthulhu Plushie
    • Deady Bear Plushie
    • Spider Plushies (Spooders)
    • Jackalope Plushie
    • Moth Plushie
    • Mushroom Plushies
    • New Plushie Designs
  • Toys
  • BackPacks
  • Merch
  • Mystery Box
  • Blog
  • Cart
  • Checkout
Home / Mystery Box

Mystery Box

Showing 1–9 of 31 results

  • Sold out! Baphy bear, baphomet bear, baphomet build a bear, goth plushies, baphybear

    Build a Bear Baphomet Plush (GLOW IN THE DARK)

    $99.00
  • Sold out! GIANT MYSTERY EGG - Easter Bunny Plushies

    GIANT MYSTERY EGG – Easter Bunny Plushies

    $60.00
  • Sold out! Halloween Trick or Treat Mystery Bags!

    Halloween Trick or Treat Mystery Bags!

    $50.00
  • Mystery 22 inch Squid Plush

    Mystery 22 inch Squid Plush

    $100.00
  • MYSTERY BABY BAPHOMET PLUSH

    MYSTERY BABY BAPHOMET PLUSH

    $100.00
  • Mystery Baby Jackalope! (Regular size)

    Mystery Baby Jackalope! (Regular size)

    $75.00
  • Sold out! MYSTERY COLOR ENERGY VAMPIRE PLUSH

    MYSTERY COLOR ENERGY VAMPIRE PLUSH

    $65.00
  • MYSTERY COLOR MUTANT BUNNY PLUSH

    MYSTERY COLOR MUTANT BUNNY PLUSH

    $50.00
  • Sold out! MYSTERY COLOR SPLITTY KITTY PLUSH

    MYSTERY COLOR SPLITTY KITTY PLUSH

    $45.00
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • →

Recent Posts

  • “What Creepy Cute Plushie are you?” Quiz
  • Creepy Cute Plush Valentines Day Mystery Bags!!
  • Creepy Cute and Customizable Valentine’s Plushies Are Here! 💖🖤
  • Creepy Cute Plushies Tour 2025! VenomDolls is on the Road.
  • Discover the Spooky Charm of Deady Bears: Wearable Spiked Collars for Goth Plushie Lovers!

Recent Comments

  1. Jj on Join the Plushie Newsletter
  2. joey on Binx the weighted Tarot Kitty (Glow in the dark)
  3. Jessica on Jynx the Weighted Tarot Kitty (Glow in the dark)
  4. Trenton on Creepy Cute Plushies Come to Life as Collectable Art Toys!
  5. Vivian on *SOLD OUT* Sad Bun Key Chain -Random Color

Plushie Styles:

  • Alien Plushie
  • Baby Baphomet Plushie
  • Bat Plushie
  • Bunny Plushie
  • Build a Bear Baphomet
  • Chibi Bat Plushies
  • Cow Plushies
  • Cat Plushie
  • Cthulhu Plushie
  • Deady Bear Plushie
  • Spider Plushie (spooders)
  • Jackalope Plushie
  • Moth Plushie
  • Mushroom Plushie

Follow us on social

  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow

Join Our Email Newsletter